01-24-2012 | #21 |
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Found Member
Posts: 4,346
|
Re: Best Rear Wheel Hub Assembly?
__________________
Frank Urbo. NCM Lifetime member # 982 Registry Founding # 237 |
01-24-2012 | #22 |
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: I live at Devens, one run at a time
Posts: 455
|
Re: Best Rear Wheel Hub Assembly?
I've come to the conclusion that they are all now made in the same factory in China. Having gone through 1-2 sets of hubs a year for the last few years I have seen random logos mixed up and they all seem to have very similar design. For me they all fail the same way - seal gets overheated, lube leaves, hub becomes junk. Front or rear, and in either front style (we run both ABS styles).
At least I got through a couple sets on Autozone's 1 year guarantee. Now I'm preparing to back date my front hubs so at least I can toss the cheap ones (sensor separate). If there is play in all directions (ie shake wheel l/r & t/b) it's a hub - if it's tight in any of those directions it's something else. 315 and 335 slicks are addictive, but they extract their price beyond just paying Hoosier... LOL! Best, - Jeff
__________________
[I]91 ZR-1 #1840, autocrossing in SCCA BSP. FIC S/S's DRM chip/Watson/Borla/lid/LW batt&headlights, springs, shocks, pads & lines, quick rack & Turn One, camber brace, 32/22mm sways, A/C halfway deleted 17x11 & 12 CCW's, 315 & 335 Hoosier A6s [/I] |
01-24-2012 | #23 |
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: grosse isle, manitoba, canada
Posts: 52
|
Re: Best Rear Wheel Hub Assembly?
The 'one factory in china' analogy isnt too far from the truth in that they do produce different quality parts for differnet customers under the same roof. I know this for a fact. What muddys the waters further is that the SAME bearing can be sold by both a better name brand retailer (eg NAPA) vs a discount retailer with a MUCH lower price (with a MUCH shorter warranty. ie you pay for the warranty). All I can say is from my experience as a journeyman mechanic here, NTN-BOWER seems to work well. Timken is probably the best known and maybe works as well but how many times have i looked at a new Timken bearing and found 'made in Romania' or wherever on it and wondered hmmmmm.....like the set of Dunlops I bought that were made in Poland; with further investigation I found they were made at the Buna rubber plant the Nazis built at Auschwitz/Birkenau. But they ran fine and lasted...I guess thats the price for globalization. Maybe those Romanian Timken bearings were the best out there? Untill I get burned I will continue to use NTN-Bower, because they have held up for me (although I dont race) and definitely have seen many people get burned using white box/private label (autozone, partsource, whathaveyou...) bearings. Thats my experience anyway. PS I'm sure youre aware a bearing that can has no play by feel can definitely growl....buy/borrow an 'electronic ear' set up....its invaluable for times like these (eg customer says LF is noisy but you can tell him, sorry sir BOTH front bearings are noisy, LF more so....or no its just your tires or torqrue converter etc) cheers! Uh oh. last call.....In short, go with what you know or trusted people advise but know that globalization can change it all in a heartbeat, as when my beloved NTN bearings are sourced from North Korea or Cuba when the opportunity presents....
Last edited by sdycke; 01-24-2012 at 09:34 PM. Reason: sober |
02-04-2012 | #24 |
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Cresson, TX
Posts: 970
|
Re: Best Rear Wheel Hub Assembly?
Put the Timken’s on and no real change so tonight I swapped the tires around between the turbo car and #140. Yep it worked, no more noise...
I guess I have two good use bearings in storage now... Cheers,
__________________
Ron Hanselman Founding Member #80 CM Lifetime Member #1093 1991 #383 Twin Turbo 1993 #099 Ruby, Jeal 368 w/Snake Skinner body 1961 White with Red Int |
02-18-2012 | #25 |
Join Date: Dec 2005
Posts: 692
|
Re: Best Rear Wheel Hub Assembly?
|
02-22-2012 | #26 |
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Cresson, TX
Posts: 970
|
Re: Best Rear Wheel Hub Assembly?
|
02-22-2012 | #27 |
Join Date: Dec 2005
Posts: 692
|
Re: Best Rear Wheel Hub Assembly?
|
02-25-2012 | #28 |
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: Kalamazoo MI
Posts: 1,753
|
Re: Best Rear Wheel Hub Assembly?
I have two complete sets of rear end parts if anyone is interested.
__________________
JOHNNY P Currently own 90 ZR-1 #845 DRM 500 engine package 90 #226 Parts car Hit me up if you need anything. |
|
|